Current:Home > MyPoinbank Exchange|He died in prison. His corpse was returned without a heart. Now his family is suing. -Blueprint Money Mastery
Poinbank Exchange|He died in prison. His corpse was returned without a heart. Now his family is suing.
Charles H. Sloan View
Date:2025-04-06 21:54:59
It's been 53 days since officials say inmate Brandon Clay Dotson was found dead in his Alabama prison bed.
On Monday,Poinbank Exchange the man's family − and a federal judge − were still waiting to learn how he died and, disturbingly, why his heart was missing from his body when it was released to relatives, court documents show.
According to a lawsuit filed Dec. 7 in the Northern District of Alabama, Dotson died Nov. 16 – the same day he was considered for parole release.
At the time of this death, court records show the 43-year-old man was housed at Ventress Correctional Facility in Clayton − a tiny town in Barbour County about 70 miles southeast of Montgomery.
Dotson was serving time for a burglary, the Alabama Department of Corrections told ABC 33/40 News, when he was found unresponsive in his cell and taken to the Health Care Unit where he was pronounced dead.
After his death, his mother, Audrey South, contacted the warden and requested her son's body be released to family "in hopes of holding his funeral before Thanksgiving Day." The state Department of Corrections, according to the suit, told her it needed to perform a routine autopsy on her son first.
Dotson's "severely decomposed" body was released Nov. 21, the complaint continues. Family "suspected foul play," so they hired a pathologist to conduct a second autopsy and, during the exam, a doctor found his heart was missing from his chest cavity.
On the heels of a hearing in federal court in downtown Birmingham last week, a judge on Monday was still working to pinpoint where Dotson's heart is located.
According to the 34-page complaint, Dotson's cause of death remained undetermined because of the removal of the heart. His heart, the lawsuit claims, is necessary to "obtain an accurate and complete determination of the circumstances surrounding the deceased’s death."
Judge assault case:Defendant caught on video attacking Las Vegas judge to return to court for sentencing
'Gross negligence'
Neither the Alabama Department of Corrections nor the Alabama Department of Forensic Sciences, which conducts autopsies for the state prison agency, could immediately be reached by USA TODAY Monday.
In addition to those state agencies, the lawsuit names other defendants including the Ventress Correctional Facility warden, several of its correction officers and the University of Alabama (UAB) Medical Center.
South and Dotson's daughter, Audrey Dotson, who jointly filed suit, allege the state Department of Corrections − or whoever who transported the body, "removed and retained" Dotson’s heart during the autopsy without their consent.
"The heart of a deceased person simply does not go missing in the absence of deliberate illegal activity or gross negligence on behalf of the entity or entities that had possession of the body prior to it being turned over to the family for burial," the lawsuit reads.
A target of violence
According to the lawsuit, in the days leading up to his death, Dotson had been in segregated housing asking for help, as "he was the target of violence by another inmate."
"Dotson was forced to vacate his assigned bed by an incarcerated man who was regularly providing Mr. Dotson with drugs, and punishing him when he failed to pay his debt for those drugs," the suit continues.
The suit claims corrections officers were aware of Dotson’s concerns for his safety, "yet did nothing to prevent the harm that came to him in the week leading up to his death."
NY driveway slaying:Jury selection to begin in trial of man who fatally shot Kaylin Gillis
Testimony and a judge's pending review
On Friday, court records show, U.S. District Judge Madeline Hughes Haikala held a hearing at Hugo Black U.S. Courthouse in an effort to find out where the heart is and why it disappeared.
Testimony revealed Dotson’s autopsy was performed by the Alabama Department of Forensic Sciences, AL.com reported and attorneys for UAB argued that no one from the school performed the initial autopsy on Dotson, nor had his body or organs ever been in their custody.
Five witnesses − the warden, the commissioner and chief deputy commissioner of the Alabama Department of Corrections, the director of the Alabama Department of Forensic Sciences, and the head of autopsies at UAB − took the stand and, according to the outlet, testified the whereabouts of the heart remain a mystery.
Lawyers for the prison system said Dotson’s heart was inside his body when it left the prison and said they do not have the heart, the outlet reported. But Alabama Department of Forensic Sciences Director Angelo Della Manna, said he had not reviewed Dotson’s case file so he could not answer questions about it.
In a standard autopsy, the outlet reported, he said the following procedures take place:
- Internal organs are "examined and then sectioned" or have "pieces of tissue cut off, to be sent for further testing to determine cause and manner of death."
- Organs are then placed in "a special biohazard bag and returned to their appropriate body cavity" but are not replaced "in the exact place where they anatomically are located."
- The tissue sectioned or cut off are "generally the only pieces of organs that would not be returned to the body."
The director, the outlet reported, could not give a reason why "a fully intact organ" would not returned to a body.
If any sections were sent for further testing, or if there was anything abnormal about the body, Della Manna testified, that information would be in Dotson’s case file and autopsy report which − according to the suit− is not yet public and has not yet been provided to Dotson's family.
The judge ordered the state to provide that report for her to review by the end of the day Monday, according to the outlet.
Jury trial and restraining order requests
Attorney Lauren Faraino, who represents the Dotson family, told the outlet she believed the university "was planning to receive the heart until lawsuit was filed."
In court Friday, the outlet reported, a university lawyer testified there was no evidence that was the case, and said the university is “certainly very sympathetic” to Dotson's family.
The suit which claims wrongful death, violation of constitutional rights, fraud, negligence and more, demands a jury trial.
It also requests a temporary restraining order to prevent the state Department of Corrections from retaining Dotson's remains and that they be returned to Dotson’s next of kin.
Natalie Neysa Alund is a senior reporter for USA TODAY. Reach her at [email protected] and follow her on X @nataliealund.
veryGood! (96375)
Related
- Bodycam footage shows high
- Unpublished works and manuscript by legendary Argentine writer Cortázar sell for $36,000 at auction
- Colombian serial killer who confessed to murdering more than 190 children dies in hospital
- Douglas Clark, convicted murderer and half of the Sunset Strip Killers, dies of natural causes
- Meet first time Grammy nominee Charley Crockett
- Douglas Clark, convicted murderer and half of the Sunset Strip Killers, dies of natural causes
- Japan’s government asks a court to revoke the legal religious status of the Unification Church
- Fear and confusion mark key moments of Lahaina residents’ 911 calls during deadly wildfire
- Jamie Foxx reps say actor was hit in face by a glass at birthday dinner, needed stitches
- Maui County releases audio of 911 calls from deadly wildfire after request from The Associated Press
Ranking
- NFL Week 15 picks straight up and against spread: Bills, Lions put No. 1 seed hopes on line
- Maui County releases audio of 911 calls from deadly wildfire after request from The Associated Press
- Russian authorities raid the homes of lawyers for imprisoned opposition leader Alexei Navalny
- Company profits, UAW profit-sharing checks on the line in strike at Ford Kentucky Truck
- North Carolina trustees approve Bill Belichick’s deal ahead of introductory news conference
- Attorney general investigates fatal police shooting of former elite fencer at his New York home
- Michael Kosta, Desus Nice, Leslie Jones among new guest hosts for 'The Daily Show'
- 5 things podcast: Book bans hit fever pitch. Who gets to decide what we can or can't read?
Recommendation
South Korean president's party divided over defiant martial law speech
Climate change sees IOC aim to choose hosts of 2030 and 2034 Winter Olympics at same time next July
In 'Eras Tour' movie, Taylor Swift shows women how to reject the mandate of one identity
2 women charged after operating unlicensed cosmetic surgery recovery house in Miami
Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
Mahomes throws TD pass, Kelce has big game with Swift watching again as Chiefs beat Broncos 19-8
Taylor Swift returns to Arrowhead Stadium to see Travis Kelce and the Chiefs face the Broncos
Factory fishing in Antarctica for krill targets the cornerstone of a fragile ecosystem